NVIDIA has found itself in the middle of a controversy. The tech giant is reportedly building an AI video foundational model that is said to have scraped copyrighted video content from YouTube and Netflix. This information spread like wildfire when conversations between NVIDIA employees on Slack were leaked by 404 Media. While working on this model, many NVIDIA employees asked their managers about legal and ethical issues, and here’s what happened
404 Media did an exclusive investigation and spoke to an anonymous former NVIDIA employee who revealed internal NVIDIA processes. According to that, NVIDIA has scraped a lot of copyrighted video content from YouTube and Netflix to train Cosmos, the AI video foundational model. NVIDIA is building this AI model to combine light simulation, physics, and intelligence in one system to enable many important applications for NVIDIA.
The leaked conversation shared by Samantha Cole, the author who wrote this copy on 404 Media, reveals NVIDIA employees raising concerns over ethical and legal issues. To this, Ming-Yu Liu, Vice President of Research at NVIDIA soon replied, “This is an executive decision. We have an umbrella approval for all of the data.”
Apart from that, many more employees reportedly also asked the same questions about legality in the process of training Cosmos. However, their project managers told them that they have the authority approval to do such work. Which authority? We don’t know that yet.
Additionally, the report also stated that NVIDIA’s Cosmos team talked about downloading different types of video content, such as Hollywood movies, Discovery Channel documentaries, and high-quality gaming footage, in a Slack conversation. Project leaders like Ming-Yu Liu said that Hollywood films could be useful for training because of their “gaming-like 3D consistency and fictional content but much higher quality.” However, he also noted the sensitivity of using this content, similar to the concerns raised by artists after the release of Stable Diffusion (SD).
According to Cole, NVIDIA is consuming copyrighted content as fast as it can to “stay competitive in the AI industry.” If this is the case, this is not going to be a fair competition then. We haven’t heard anything from NVIDIA about this yet, so let’s see how it is planning to counter these allegations.